Many investors think owning multiple mutual funds automatically creates diversification. In reality, many portfolios contain the same stocks repeated across different funds — a problem called portfolio overlap.
This duplication increases risk without improving returns. You may believe you hold 6–8 funds, but in reality your money could be concentrated in the same companies.
A proper mutual fund overlap check helps identify duplication, reduce unnecessary funds, and build a simpler portfolio with better diversification.
This guide explains how overlap happens, how to detect it, and how to restructure your portfolio without reducing growth potential.
This guide is for SIP investors, long-term wealth builders, and anyone holding multiple mutual funds.
What Is Mutual Fund Overlap
Mutual fund overlap happens when two or more funds invest in the same stocks in similar proportions.
Example:
-
Fund A holds Stock X
-
Fund B also holds Stock X
-
Fund C also holds Stock X
You unknowingly increase exposure to the same company.
This reduces true diversification.
Why Mutual Fund Overlap Is Dangerous
Many investors assume more funds mean lower risk. The opposite can happen.
Key Problems Caused by Overlap
-
Portfolio concentration increases
-
Diversification reduces
-
Risk rises during market fall
-
Returns become similar across funds
-
Extra funds add complexity without benefit
You take more risk without additional reward.
Signs Your Portfolio Has Overlap
You may have overlap if:
-
You own multiple funds from same category
-
Returns across funds look identical
-
Portfolio size keeps growing without clarity
-
Too many funds in same market segment
-
Performance does not improve despite adding funds
More funds does not mean better portfolio.
Who Should Perform an Overlap Check
Best suited for:
-
Investors holding more than 3–4 funds
-
SIP investors across multiple schemes
-
Long-term wealth builders
-
Investors with large portfolios
-
People unsure about diversification
Less necessary for:
-
Investors holding 1–2 funds
-
Beginners starting investments
How Overlap Happens (Common Reasons)
Understanding causes helps avoid future duplication.
1. Buying Multiple Funds in Same Category
Example:
-
Two large-cap funds
-
Multiple index funds
-
Similar diversified funds
They often hold the same companies.
2. Chasing Past Performance
Investors buy new top-performing funds without reviewing existing portfolio.
3. Following Multiple Advice Sources
Different advisors may recommend similar funds.
4. Lack of Portfolio Review
Investors rarely review holdings periodically.
Overlap grows silently.
How to Check Mutual Fund Overlap — Step-by-Step
Follow this simple audit process.
Step 1 — List All Mutual Funds
Create a list of:
-
Fund name
-
Category
-
Investment amount
-
Purpose
This provides clarity.
Step 2 — Compare Top Holdings
Check top stocks held by each fund.
Look for:
-
Same companies appearing repeatedly
-
High percentage exposure to same stocks
Repeated holdings indicate overlap.
Step 3 — Compare Fund Category
Funds in same category often overlap.
Examples:
-
Large-cap vs large-cap
-
Index vs index
-
Sector vs sector
Avoid duplicate exposure.
Step 4 — Measure Overlap Level
General rule:
-
Low overlap → good diversification
-
Moderate overlap → acceptable
-
High overlap → restructuring required
Focus on reducing high overlap.
Example — Overlap in a Typical Portfolio
Investor holds:
-
Large-cap fund A
-
Large-cap fund B
-
Index fund
All hold similar top companies.
Result:
-
Portfolio concentrated in same stocks
-
No real diversification
Reducing duplicate funds improves efficiency.
How Many Mutual Funds Should You Own
A simple diversified portfolio usually needs:
Ideal Portfolio Size
| Portfolio Type | Number of Funds |
|---|---|
| Beginner | 2–3 funds |
| Moderate investor | 3–5 funds |
| Advanced portfolio | 5–6 funds |
More funds rarely improve results.
How to Reduce Overlap Without Losing Diversification
Step 1 — Identify Duplicate Funds
Select funds with highest overlap.
Step 2 — Retain Best Performer
Keep fund with better track record or lower cost.
Step 3 — Remove Extra Funds Gradually
Reduce unnecessary schemes over time.
Step 4 — Diversify Across Categories
Choose different asset classes or fund types.
Simpler portfolio performs better.
Better Diversification Strategy
Instead of multiple similar funds, use structured allocation.
Example Diversified Portfolio
-
Large-cap fund
-
Mid-cap fund
-
International fund
-
Debt fund
Different asset classes reduce overlap risk.
Category-Based Diversification Model
| Asset Type | Role |
|---|---|
| Equity large-cap | Stability |
| Equity mid/small | Growth |
| Debt funds | Risk control |
| International funds | Global exposure |
This structure improves balance.
The “3–Fund Rule” for Simplicity
Many investors achieve strong diversification using:
-
One large-cap fund
-
One growth-focused fund
-
One debt or stabilising fund
Simple portfolios are easier to manage and review.
Common Mistakes Investors Make
Avoid these errors:
-
Buying funds based on popularity
-
Holding too many similar funds
-
Ignoring portfolio review
-
Confusing quantity with diversification
-
Switching frequently without strategy
Clarity improves investment quality.
When Overlap Is Acceptable
Some overlap is normal.
Acceptable situations:
-
Small duplication percentage
-
Different investment strategy despite shared stocks
-
Diversification across market segments
Goal is not zero overlap — but controlled overlap.
How Often Should You Check Portfolio Overlap
Recommended review frequency:
-
Every 6–12 months
-
After adding new fund
-
After major market changes
Regular review maintains portfolio quality.
Benefits of Reducing Portfolio Overlap
After restructuring, investors typically see:
-
Better diversification
-
Lower portfolio risk
-
Clearer investment strategy
-
Easier tracking
-
Improved long-term stability
Simplicity strengthens portfolio performance.
Mutual Fund Overlap Check Checklist
-
List all mutual funds
-
Compare top holdings
-
Identify duplicate categories
-
Reduce unnecessary funds
-
Maintain 3–5 fund structure
-
Review annually
Structured review improves financial outcomes.
Conclusion
A proper mutual fund overlap check ensures your investments are truly diversified rather than repeatedly invested in the same companies. Holding too many similar funds increases risk, complicates management, and reduces efficiency.
A simpler, well-diversified portfolio with fewer funds often delivers better results. The goal is not more funds — but smarter allocation.
Diversification works only when investments are genuinely different.
FAQs
What is mutual fund overlap?
It occurs when multiple funds hold the same stocks, reducing diversification.
Is mutual fund overlap bad?
High overlap increases risk and reduces diversification benefits.
How many mutual funds should I hold?
Most investors need only 3–5 funds for proper diversification.
Can two funds from different categories overlap?
Yes. Different funds may still hold similar stocks.
How often should I review portfolio overlap?
At least once a year or after adding new investments.